Who wins the Melbourne Cup

Gary Crispe - Racing and Sports CEO & Australian Timeform Representative

1. (6) Hartnell

2. (12) Jameka

3. (5) Exospheric

Best Roughie: (17) Almandin

Adam Blencowe - Racing and Sports Senior Handicapper

1. (8) Wicklow Brave

2. (1) Big Orange

3. (4) Bondi Beach

Best Roughie: (21) Secret Number

Chris Scholtz - Racing and Sports Contributing Editor

1. (21) Secret Number

2. (20) Oceanographer

3. (12) Jameka

Best Roughie: (19) Grey Lion

Dean Croker - Journalist & Form Analyst

1. (6) Hartnell

2. (8) Wicklow Brave

3. (5) Exospheric

Best Roughie: (23) Qewy

Simon Dinopoulos - Journalist & Form Analyst

1. (6) Hartnell

2. (12) Jameka

3. (8) Wicklow Brave

Best Roughie: (3) Curren Mirotic

Don Mackay - Journalist & Form Analyst

1. (12) Jameka

2. (20) Oceanographer

3. (6) Hartnell

Best Roughie: (16) Beautiful Romance

Alex Steedman - Journalist & Form Analyst

1. (17) Almandin

2. (5) Exospheric

3. (20) Oceanographer

Best Roughie: (19) Grey Lion

Ken Warren - Journalist & Form Analyst

1. (8) Wicklow Brave

2. (5) Exospheric

3. (6) Hartnell

Best Roughie: (21) Secret Number

Wayne Bristow - Form Analyst & Racing and Sports On-Line Magazine Editor

1. (17) Almandin

2. (8) Wicklow Brave

3. (1) Big Orange

Best Roughie: (23) Qewy

RACING AND SPORTS CONSENSUS SELECTIONS FOR THE CUP

1. (6) Hartnell

2. (8) Wicklow Brave

3. (12) Jameka

Best Roughies: (19) Grey Lion, (21) Secret Number & (23) Qewy